Alison stone, essentialism and antiessentialism in. Because all women are located within this complex history, they are identifiable as belonging to a determinate social group, despite sharing no common understanding or experience of femininity. Antiessentialism, multiculturalism and the recognition of. I am going to discuss the development of feminist theories as to the sources of gender inequality and its pervasiveness, and the different feminist political solutions and. In the fourth chapter, i will formulate a concept of woman in a meaningful way that is valuable for feminist theory and does not fall prey to potential essentialist challenges. The idea that women have a genealogy thus reconciles antiessentialism with feminist politics. A defence of anti essentialism 16 alison stone 3 kristeva and the transmissions of the intertext. The variety of feminisms and their contribution to gender.
In this paper i distinguish among different theories of gender essentialism and sketch out a taxonomy of gender essentialisms. How adaptable is feminist legal theory to issues that challenge the very notion of what it. The logic of late feminism 46 gillian howie and ashley tauchert. Find materials for this course in the pages linked along the left. Foucault dismissed the search for a return to origins as platonic essentialism, preferring to stress the contingent nature of human practices.
Feminisms challenge to biological essentialism the debate over sex differences has a considerable history in the western world. Strong variants of social constructionism are liable to invert rather than resolve the problems of strong essentialism, including those of its biological reductionist guises. More particularly, in looking especially at comparative law scholarship on southeast asia, it asks if there are any lessons that comparative law theory can learn about how to account for commonality and difference in large and diverse contexts from the perspectives of intersectionality and antiessentialism that have been developed in feminist. Studying religion and feminism october, 2016 0 comments in features, responses by sammy bishop in her interview with the religious studies project, dawn llewellyn gives a succinct and wellconsidered account of. Studying religion and feminism october, 2016 0 comments in features, responses by sammy bishop in her interview with the religious studies project, dawn llewellyn gives a succinct and wellconsidered account of the tricky relationship between feminism and religion. A group of established feminist legal scholars are translating thirdwave ideas and methodologies into a vibrant legal theory. Thus, antiessentialism seemed to undermine feminism both as social critique and as a political movement for social change. Therefore, gender essentialism is not automatically bad for the intersectional feminist movement. But the view that homosexuality is a monolith is not at all an essential feature of essentialism. It is also used as a rationale for pigeonholing, offering limited education, hiring discrimination, etc. My project of reconceiving women as having a genealogy is loosely derived from. Whats antiessentialism and intersectionality anyway.
Essentialism the art and popular culture encyclopedia. Pdf what is gender essentialism charlotte witt academia. Our hope is that the essay will both challenge the prevailing ways in which many scholars, including some feminists and critical race theorists, frame anti essentialism, intersectionality, and dominance theory, and underscore the critical importance of attending to how racial power is gendered and gender subordination is racialized. Readings feminist thought womens and gender studies. Antifoundationalism 912 words exact match in snippet view article find links to article action. Radical feminists view society as fundamentally a patriarchy. Essentialism, social constructionism, and beyond andrew. Oct 25, 2010 sometimes, conceptualizing feminist terms can be difficult. Thus, a feminism that centres on essentialist notions of women, gender relations and gender difference contributes only to a hardening of. The central problem of third wave feminist theory, then, is that it risks undermining feminism both as a political practice and as a critique of existing society. I argue that their work, though powerful and brilliant in many ways, relies on what i call gender essentialism the notion that a unitary, essential womens experi. The concept of essence is problematic, but not for some of the epistemological and ontological reasons put forward by antiessentialism. This article revisits the ethical and political questions raised by feminist debates over essentialism, the belief that there are properties essential to women and which all women share. In the theoretical literature it is generally assumed that essentialism is the same as uniformismconformism often made explicit in lesbian feminist theory.
Essentialism and anti essentialism in feminist philosophy. Feminists widespread rejection of essentialism has threatened to undermine feminist politics. Comparative law, antiessentialism and intersectionality. Antiessentialism, sexual agency and thirdwave feminism. Getting it and losing it martha minow race and essentialism in feminist legal theory angela p. Within feminist philosophical and theoretical contexts, third wave feminism may be defined as encompassing all critical work that points to the homogenizing or exclusive tendencies of earlier dominant feminisms heyes, antiessentialism 161. Here is a short article i wrote reflecting on the womens movements challenges to biological essentialism first published to the occupy times of london website here. In fact, i think that the firstprinciple status of antiessentialism in feminist theory is a result of the illicit and tacit combination, and sometimes conflation, of these arguments. I read an article called, anti essentialism and intersectionality. I argue that their work, though powerful and brilliant in many ways, relies on what i call gender essentialismthe notion that a unitary, essential womens experi. I read an article called, antiessentialism and intersectionality. A black feminist critique of antidiscrimination doctrine, feminist theory and antiracist.
Approaches to contemporary legal theory by darren rosenblum and bridget crawford. How does feminist legal theory deal with diversity, conflict and contestation among women. I focus primarily on the difference between essentialism about a kind and essentialism about an individual. Our hope is that the essay will both challenge the prevailing ways in which many scholars, including some feminists and critical race theorists, frame antiessentialism, intersectionality, and dominance theory, and underscore the critical importance of attending to how racial power is gendered and gender subordination is racialized. On the one hand, feminists note that culture and religion are often cited as justifications for denying women a range of basic rights.
A commentary on the essence of antiessentialism in feminist. Against essentialism in feminist philosophy, in stacy gillis, gillian howie and becky munford eds. Sometimes, conceptualizing feminist terms can be difficult. Pdf essentialism and antiessentialism in feminist philosophy. In this article, i discuss some of the writings of feminist legal theorists catharine mackinnon and robin west. However, i also note that intersectionality and antiessentialism have not been conclusive of how to address, and more importantly to make sense of, womens diversity and that these challenges are consistent and parallel with comparative law theory, which is still searching for its own narrative. In feminist theory and gender studies, gender essentialism is the attribution of fixed essences to men and women this idea that men and women are fundamentally different continues to be a. Nov, 2017 yet in the same way, the negative arguments associated with essentialism also do not make normative claims about how we ought to act, merely about what it is to be a woman. Even with diversity among womens experiences, women are oppressed as women by constructions that. Womens essence is assumed to be universal and is generally identified with those characteristics viewed as being specifically feminine. Signs, mothers and speaking in tongues 30 mary orr 4 feminist dissonance. This is often used as an explanation for why there are so few women in science and technology.
The essentialism debate in feminist theory and practice. What doesmight feminist legal action look like, and what has it achieved. Apr 09, 2016 home literary criticism strategic essentialism. Women have something valuable to contribute to every aspect of the world. Historically, essentialist ideas of gender have served both to rationalise and, conversely, to contest social, legal and political inequities.
Initially, in its 1980s iterations, this feminist work was organized as a critique of essentialism, of the. Harris 2019 marks thirty years since the publication of kimberle crenshaws groundbreaking article, demarginalizing the intersection of race and sex. Yet in the same way, the negative arguments associated with essentialism also do not make normative claims about how we ought to act, merely about what it is to be a woman. Is gender essentialism bad for the intersectional feminist. Strategic essentialism literary theory and criticism. Tools to dismantle the masters house by trina grillo which spoke volumes to me and helped me understand some unfamiliar concepts. Of antiessentialism, intersectionality, and dominance theory devon w.
Strategic essentialism by nasrullah mambrol on april 9, 2016 1. The concept of essentialism states that there are innate, essential differences between men and women. Faced with these problems, antiantiessentialists reconsidered how far some form of essentialism might be necessary for feminist social criticism and political activism. Pdf essentialism has provoked feminist debate from the 1970s to today. In feminist theory and gender studies, gender essentialism is the attribution of fixed essences to men and women this idea that men and women are fundamentally different continues to be a matter of contention. In the theoretical literature it is generally assumed that essentialism is the same as uniformismconformism often made explicit in lesbianfeminist theory.
Judith butler, whose declared aim in gender trouble is to outline a feminist. Cain race, racism, and feminist legal theory marlee kline demarginalizing the. Because one can regard feminist legal theory as a subcategory of feminist theory, this debate can have an impact on feminist legal theory as well. Psychological essentialism is an intriguing concept that has generated multiple lines of theory and research across several of psychologys subdisciplines. Anti anti essentialists have responded that anti essentialism can undermine feminism as a political movement, defending either strategic essentialism or alternative accounts of women as a social. Feminisms challenge to biological essentialism raewyn connell. It also foregrounds issues of global concern and scope. Deconstructing historiography, posits that although essentialism is highly problematic for the knowledge it creates about the other, there is sometimes a political and social need for what she calls strategic essentialism. In feminist theory and gender studies, gender essentialism is the attribution of a fixed essence to women. Essentialism and antiessentialism in feminist philosophy. Initially, in its 1980s iterations, this feminist work. The variety of feminisms and their contribution to gender equality introduction my focus is the continuities and discontinuities in recent feminist ideas and perspectives.
How adaptable is feminist legal theory to issues that challenge the very notion of what it means to be a woman. The concept of essence is problematic, but not for some of the epistemological and ontological reasons put forward by anti essentialism. In the 1970s and 80s, feminists led the way in crafting and advocating for policies to address domestic violence in the united states and those. Although at one level, they reflect abstract ontological intuitions about the nature of social reality, at another they have important implications for everyday social perception and. Gender essentialism is a concept used to examine the attribution of fixed, intrinsic, innate qualities to women and men. Within feminist philosophical and theoretical contexts, third wave feminism may be defined as encompassing all critical work that points to the. Alison stone, essentialism and antiessentialism in feminist. An updated feminist view of intimate partner violence.
1109 245 1386 753 107 986 975 1436 1695 1198 64 54 1315 1337 1187 1071 208 1397 31 800 1518 632 433 1668 1634 1019 392 345 1452 1211 455 1454 219 233 214 500 1552 687 1411 522 80 825 265 1211 1075 1314 1491 723 892 411